Articles

Navigating NIM Challenges Amid Rising Interest Rates for Credit Unions

Written by JD Pisula | Nov 19, 2026, 9:22:00 PM

When will higher rates translate into higher margins? Higher rates can lift loan and investment yields, but the path to improved margins is rarely smooth. Funding costs tend to respond faster than asset yields, so the early stage of a rising-rate cycle can squeeze margins before any relief appears. Credit unions that plan for this lag will likely be in a stronger position than those counting on an immediate payoff.

Funding Side Pressure

Within months of a rate increase, deposit and borrowing costs can begin climbing, well before higher loan and investment yields have had time to build. That fast climb can erode margin quickly, before the asset-side benefits start to build.

  • Share certificates are high beta. As rates climb, members move money out of regular shares and into certificates. Even if you don’t touch your share rates, your cost of funds rises. The Federal Reserve Bank of New York documented this shift across the banking industry during the 2022 to 2023 tightening cycle, as noninterest-bearing deposits declined and time deposits and FHLB advances grew to replace them.
  • FHLB and other wholesale borrowings reprice immediately. Credit unions that lean on advances feel that higher cost right away. Federal Reserve research on bank funding costs covering three decades of rate cycles finds that non-deposit liabilities consistently adjust more than deposits.
  • Loan demand slows. Higher rates cut mortgage originations and refi volume, while affordability pressure dampens consumer lending.
  • Variable-rate loans reprice right away. HELOCs, commercial lines and variable-rate cards reset to the higher rate within months. For most credit unions, though, these balances are a small slice of the loan book, so the lift to total NIM is likely modest.
  • The investment portfolio will likely improve only as older, low-yield securities mature or roll into higher yields. Most credit union portfolios that we see lean fixed-rate, so the full lift can take years depending on duration.
  • Auto loans are primarily fixed-rate. The benefit comes as the book pays down and gets replaced with new loans at higher rates. That takes roughly two to three years. Most auto loans pay off well ahead of schedule. A Federal Reserve study of auto loan prepayments found that about 45 percent of auto loans originated since the early 2000s were paid off within the first 36 months.
  • Fixed-rate mortgages carry the higher rate on new originations right away, yet new volume is a small share of the portfolio in any given year. Rising rates slow prepayments, so older low-rate loans stay on the books longer and the full benefit can take many years to appear.

What helps, and why it takes time

When rates rise, new loans and investments are priced at the higher rate almost immediately, and variable-rate balances adjust at their next reset date. Net interest margin, however, reflects the yield on the entire balance sheet, and most of that balance sheet was booked at older, lower rates. Those balances only turn over as existing loans pay down and securities mature. As a result, the full benefit of higher rates can take years to show up in earnings, offering slow relief for the funding side pressures.

 

Core deposits are the main source of near-term relief. Regular shares and checking accounts are low beta, meaning members expect only modest rate increases on these balances. Holding that cost steady while asset yields gradually climb is where most of the early margin help comes from. Research from the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland on interest rate risk at U.S. credit unions found that credit union deposit rates respond only modestly to changes in market rates, which acts as a natural hedge when rates rise.

Your Mission in the Margin

Margin performance matters because it funds the work a credit union does for its members. Net interest income supports better member pricing and builds the capital that carries the institution through difficult cycles, so managing it well is central to the mission.

A disciplined asset and liability management strategy offers leadership a view of how the balance sheet is likely to behave under different rate paths. Modeling deposit migration and stress testing repricing assumptions allow the ALCO to act early when funding costs begin to climb.

Loan pricing deserves the same attention. Rates on new loans should reflect the credit union's current cost of funds and the risk being taken, so that each origination adds to margin over its life. Pricing that lags the market can lock in thin spreads for years, particularly on longer-term auto and mortgage loans.

 

Accolade Investment Advisory, LLC (“Accolade”) is an SEC-registered investment adviser. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Certain services described may be non-advisory in nature and are provided under separate agreements.

This material is for informational purposes only and reflects current market conditions and opinions, which are subject to change. Past performance is not indicative of future results. No assurance can be given that any strategy will be successful or any expectations will be realized. This material does not constitute investment advice. Decisions should be based on a client’s specific objectives, financial situation, and risk tolerance.